Shannon Sharpe isn’t bought on the narrative that San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy is elite.
On yesterday’s section of “First Take,” Sharpe shared that he believes Purdy’s unbelievable manufacturing is extra of a testomony to the scenario he’s in reasonably than his pure potential.
Sharpe famous that as a result of San Francisco boasts one of the vital dynamic collections of offensive expertise within the NFL, a lot much less is requested of Purdy than different quarterbacks within the league.
“On this system, the flexibility to run the soccer with Christian McCaffrey and all of the weapons, as a result of all he has to do is simply not flip it over, get it in (Brandon) Aiyuk’s palms, get it in Deebo (Samuel’s) palms, get it in (George) Kittle’s palms, and allow them to do the work. However no, he’s not elite,” Sharp mentioned. “[By] no stretch of the creativeness is he elite.”
To be honest, a mind-boggling quantities of expertise encompass Purdy in San Francisco’s offense. However that didn’t cease Ryan Clark from giving Purdy excessive reward.
“Doing what he does, the place he does it, with the individuals he does it with, he’s a top-five quarterback,” Clark said. “Not solely is he a top-five quarterback, he’s a top-two MVP candidate. Brock Purdy is elite. Once I’m watching that sport Sunday night time, I lastly stopped combating it, and I mentioned, ‘You recognize what, it doesn’t matter the place he comes from. It doesn’t matter how he acquired there. It doesn’t matter who surrounds him. Brock Purdy is an elite quarterback.”
Brock Purdy’s Manufacturing Is Elite, However Shannon Sharpe Nonetheless May Be On To One thing
It’s exhausting to argue the truth that Purdy performs like top-of-the-line quarterbacks within the NFL. Via 5 video games, he has 1,271 passing yards (ninth finest within the league), a 72.1 completion share (second), 9 landing passes (seventh), and nil interceptions (tied for lowest amongst qualifying quarterbacks).
Neglect the expertise narrative for a second, to be high 10 in all these classes is totally spectacular. It’s additionally an enormous purpose why he at present has the third-best odds to win the NFL MVP award. You’ll be able to see why Clark and others consider Purdy ought to get extra recognition for his play.
However would he have the identical degree of success in Arizona, New England, or Inexperienced Bay, the place the scenario isn’t as nice? As a result of that is the NFL and never Madden, we’ll by no means know.
And that’s precisely why Sharpe’s argument holds weight.
“He’s a product of the system,” Sharpe mentioned. “Now, that’s not to remove from what he’s doing. It’s okay for him to be within the MVP dialogue and never be [Chiefs QB] Patrick Mahomes or not be [Dolphins QB] Previous [Tagovailoa]or not be an elite quarterback. He nonetheless has to go on the market and function. He simply doesn’t should do as a lot as, say, these different guys.”
Chris Canty, the third speaker on this section’s dialogue, added that it’s too quickly to find out if Purdy is within the higher echelon of NFL quarterbacks. Canty mentioned he’ll want Purdy to play for a short while longer for him to kind a extra strong opinion.
“However I’ll say this, it’s trending in the suitable route,” he added.
Purdy and the 49ers kickoff in opposition to the Cleveland Browns at 1 p.m. tomorrow. We’ll see if Purdy continues his elite begin to the season.