What Does ‘Xbox Tax’ Mean

The Recreation Awards, hosted by Geoff Keighley, is closing in on its tenth present on December 7, 2023, and its many nominees have been revealed to the general public. 2023 was an exceptionally sturdy yr for video video games on PC, PS5, Change, and Xbox Sequence X/S, giving their related classes loads of sturdy contenders. Whereas some video games have been snubbed on the Recreation Awards as traditional, the varied set of Alan Wake 2, Balder’s Gate 3, The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom, Marvel’s Spider-Man 2, Resident Evil 4and Tremendous Mario Bros. Surprise makes for a delightful Recreation of the Yr unfold.

Sadly, a notable absence from the Recreation of the Yr nominees is not sitting properly with its group. Regardless of having a number of representatives in different classes, no Xbox console exclusives are within the operating for the GOTY award. Whereas this wasn’t as noticeable in 2022 given Xbox Recreation Studios’ gentle output, 2023 noticed the discharge of Starfield alongside a number of different celebrated exclusives like Hello-Fi Rush and Forza Motorsport. The dimensions of this award snub motivated Xbox followers to look again on the Recreation Awards’ historical past, shedding gentle on a pattern that some have taken to calling the “Xbox Tax.”

RELATED: The Recreation Awards 2023: Predicting the Recreation of the Yr Winner

The Which means and Historical past of The Xbox Tax

“Xbox Tax” is shorthand for the perceived discrimination by the Recreation Awards in opposition to any title related to Xbox, and it rapidly started trending on social media after the 2023 Recreation Awards’ nominees have been introduced. Proof for it was drawn from the historical past of Recreation of the Yr classes all through the Spike Video Recreation Awards, VGX, and the Recreation Awards. For the reason that Spike Video Recreation Awards started in 2003, solely 5 years have featured Microsoft Recreation Studios titles within the Recreation of the Yr class. Moreover, after Halo: Attain’s nomination in 2010, no extra Xbox video games have been nominated for GOTY awards at Spike and Keighley’s exhibits. The Xbox video games that ran for Spike’s GOTY class and their respective years are:

• Halo 2 – 2004
• Gears of Struggle – 2006
• Halo 3 – 2007
• Gears of Struggle 2 – 2008
• Halo: Attain – 2010

In the meantime, video games from Sony, Nintendo, and third-party publishers are flourishing. Since The Recreation Awards changed the Spike Video Recreation Awards and VGX in 2014, Sony has solely missed the GOTY vote for that yr, whereas Nintendo did not have GOTY nominees in 2016 and 2018. Each have been current for VGX’s Recreation of the Yr class in 2013, and whereas Nintendo steadily missed Spike’s GOTY nominees, Sony was current as a rule. Sony and Nintendo have each received GOTY awards, which Xbox could not handle whereas represented by fan-favorite Halo and Gears of Struggle titles. Contemplating the Xbox consoles’ dominance whereas the Spike Awards have been operating, it’s curious that Microsoft has struggled to even get nominated for GOTY awards.

RELATED: Recreation Awards 2023 Snub Highlights Constant Difficulty with the Award Present

Why The Xbox Tax Is not Actual

Nonetheless, that does not imply that online game award exhibits are conspiring in opposition to Microsoft. There are explanation why Microsoft’s video games have not been a part of GOTY nominations, they usually stem from the folks tasked with setting the awards up. Nominees and winners at Spike and Geoff Keighley’s exhibits are voted on by juries fabricated from gaming information representatives. The intent of those teams is to solid a large web over the business, and post-2017 Recreation Awards exhibits not solely expanded this council to over fifty publications, but additionally started accepting votes from non-English sources by 2019. It bears noting that Microsoft, Sony, Nintendo, and AMD, in addition to a number of different publishers, have been charged with choosing the organizations to kind these juries, so no specific firm ought to have a bonus.

Whereas representatives’ views have an effect on the nomination course of, the jury’s aim is to simulate the opinions of the common gaming fanatic. To that finish, Recreation of the Yr nominees aren’t chosen by way of gross sales or evaluation scores, however quite the adoration a sport evokes in its gamers. As an example, Starfield‘s Metacritic opinions are principally optimistic, however solely 19 critic scores out of 168 whole opinions are good, whereas each sport within the 2023 Recreation Awards GOTY class has a better proportion of good rankings. Accounting for the combined consumer opinions Starfield amassed since launch, it could not win sufficient gamers over to overhaul video games like Alan Wake 2 and Baldur’s Gate 3 in securing GOTY votes.

The primary takeaway from all that is that since Halo: Attain made the 2010 Spike Awards GOTY class, Microsoft hasn’t launched something that’s hooked gamers in the identical means. No Xbox exclusives have achieved the mainstream recognition of even Marvel’s Spider-Man for over a decade, regardless of the perfect efforts of properties like Halo, Gears of Struggle, Forzaand even acquisitions like Minecraft and DOOM. 2023’s Recreation Awards have been proper to function Hello-Fi Rush, Forza Motorsport, Starfieldand Diablo 4 as Microsoft representatives, however even with Hello-Fi Rush incomes as many nominations as some GOTY contenders, no Xbox sport made it to the GOTY class.

With Microsoft’s present Recreation Cross mannequin favoring smaller releases and live-service titles like Halo Infinitefollowers ought to put together to see this pattern proceed. Not all hope is misplaced, nonetheless; the Recreation Awards’ GOTY class is thought to favor epic single-player adventures, and Xbox’s upcoming titles Avowed, Hellblade 2and Fable all match that mould. As issues stand, Microsoft isn’t at risk of shedding GOTY awards to a diabolical “Xbox Tax,” its priorities simply have to shift towards pleasing gamers like Halo and Gears of Struggle did again in Xbox’s heyday.

MORE: December 7 is Going to Be a Huge Day for Xbox Players