Copyright © AFP 2017-2023. All rights reserved.
There was a wave of misinformation about celebrities purportedly displaying help for Israelis or Palestinians for the reason that Israel-Hamas warfare erupted on October 7, 2023. Footballer Cristiano Ronaldo is the newest star to be focused, when a video of him was considered a whole lot of hundreds of instances in social media posts that falsely claimed it confirmed him grabbing an Israeli journalist’s microphone in an expression of solidarity with Palestinians. The outburst actually occurred in 2016, years earlier than the warfare, and the reporter was Portuguese.
“The second when Ronaldo throws an Israeli journalist’s microphone,” reads Indonesian-language textual content on a TikTok video, posted on October 12, 2023.
The video, which has greater than 500,000 views, reveals a reporter attempting to interview Cristiano Ronaldo earlier than the Portuguese footballer grabs his microphone and throws it away.
The 11-second footage additionally reveals an Israeli flag emoji on the reporter and curse phrases directed at Israel.
The clip then reveals a photograph of Ronaldo apparently lifting his soccer jersey to disclose a T-shirt that claims “Save Palestine”, adopted by an image of him holding an indication that seems to learn “Everybody with Palestine” in Spanish, and a photograph of him carrying a inexperienced scarf.
Screenshot of the false publish, taken on December 8, 2023The video additionally unfold on TikTok right here and right here, and on video-sharing app SnackVideo, racking up greater than 80,000 views.
The movies surfaced after Hamas militants launched an assault on Israel on October 7, 2023, killing round 1,200 folks, largely civilians, and taking round 240 hostages, in response to Israeli officers.
In response, Israel launched a navy marketing campaign towards Hamas, killing greater than 17,000 folks, largely civilians and together with hundreds of youngsters, in response to Gaza’s Hamas-run authorities.
2016 outburst
Key phrase searches on Google discovered the video really reveals Ronaldo being interviewed by Diogo Torres — a reporter from Portuguese broadcaster CMTV — when the Portugal crew had a morning stroll throughout the Euro 2016 match in France.
The unique video was printed by varied media channels, together with CMTV and soccer information outlet Purpose, on June 22, 2016 (archived hyperlinks right here and right here).
Beneath is a screenshot comparability of the video shared in false publish (left) and the CMTV video printed by Purpose in 2016 (proper):
Screenshot comparability of the video in false publish (left) and the CMTV video printed by Purpose in 2016 (proper)In keeping with CMTV, Torres requested Ronaldo: “Are you prepared for this recreation?” earlier than the soccer star grabbed his microphone and threw it right into a lake.
CMTV’s brand might be seen on the reporter’s crimson microphone (archived hyperlink).
As reported by CMTV and British tabloid The Mirror in July 2016, two divers recovered the microphone from the lake and it might be auctioned off for charity (archived hyperlinks right here and right here).
Beneath is a screenshot comparability of the microphone within the video (left), the microphone after it was retrieved from the lake (centre) and the emblem of CMTV (proper):
Screenshot comparability of the microphone within the video (left), the microphone after it was retrieved from the lake (centre) and the emblem of CMTV (proper)British journalist Dan Walker wrote about Ronaldo’s outburst in his 2016 e-book “Magic, Mud and Maradona”, the place he described Torres as a Portuguese journalist — not an Israeli journalist (archived hyperlink).
Information experiences concerning the incident, together with right here and right here, additionally stated Torres was a Portuguese reporter (archived hyperlinks right here and right here).
Ronaldo’s pictures
In the meantime, the image apparently displaying Ronaldo lifting his soccer jersey to disclose a “Save Palestine” T-shirt is doctored.
A reverse picture search on Google discovered the unique picture printed by AFP on February 21, 2010, and it reveals the phrase “Madeira” on Ronaldo’s T-shirt.
The picture’s caption reads: “Actual Madrid’s Portuguese ahead Cristiano Ronaldo lifts his jersey to show the title of the island Madeira, written on his shirt, as he celebrates scoring towards Villarreal throughout their Spanish League soccer match at Santiago Bernabeu stadium in Madrid on February 21, 2010.”
AFP additionally reported on the time that Ronaldo had devoted the objective to his residence island of Madeira after it was hit by a mudslide.
Beneath is a screenshot comparability of the doctored image (left) and the real picture on the AFP Discussion board web site (proper):
Screenshot comparability of the doctored image (left) and the real picture on the AFP Discussion board web site (proper)The image apparently displaying Ronaldo holding a placard saying “Everybody with Palestine” in Spanish can also be doctored.
A key phrase search discovered the unique picture printed by The Related Press information company on Could 18, 2018 (archived hyperlink).
It reveals the Portuguese footballer holding an indication saying “Everybody with Lorca” throughout a go to to the Spanish city after it was hit by a lethal earthquake.
AFP additionally printed an image, which was taken on the identical day, displaying Ronaldo standing subsequent to Togolese footballer Emmanuel Adebayor, who’s holding the identical signal.
Beneath is a screenshot comparability of the doctored image (left) and The Related Press’s picture (proper):
Screenshot comparability of the doctored image (left) and the real picture from The Related Press (proper)Moreover, the picture of Ronaldo carrying a inexperienced scarf shouldn’t be linked to the Israel-Hamas warfare.
The image was taken on February 22, 2023 — months earlier than the warfare erupted — throughout a photoshoot for his membership, Al-Nassr of Saudi Arabia.
The unique handout image was printed by a number of information businesses, together with Anadolu Company and AFP, with a caption that reads: “Cristiano Ronaldo of Al Nassr performs sword dance with conventional garments inside the celebrations for Saudi Arabia’s founding anniversary in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia on February 22, 2023.”
Beneath is a screenshot comparability of the picture shared within the false publish (left) and the real picture on the AFP Discussion board web site (proper):
Screenshot comparability of the picture shared within the false publish (left) and the real picture on the AFP Discussion board web site (proper)AFP has debunked varied false claims about Ronaldo purportedly supporting Palestinians, such because the soccer star snubbing Israel’s president and refusing to shake fingers with an Israeli.
